Manchester United are sliding toward the relegation zone and preparing to appoint Mauricio Pochettino as their third permanent manager in three seasons following the dismissal of Michael Carrick.
The revolving door at Old Trafford has spun once again. Following a dismal run of one win in 10 matches, Manchester United have sacked Michael Carrick and turned their attention to former Tottenham and Chelsea boss Mauricio Pochettino.
With the club languishing in the relegation zone, supporters are once again left questioning whether this appointment signals the dawn of a genuine new era or simply more of the same dysfunction at the top.
“Changing, changing, changing manager. But what about other areas?” Lisandro Martinez’s question will remain unanswered for now because the conversation has shifted to what has become an annual autumn/winter affair at Manchester United: changing the head coach.
A Historic Slump Under Pressure
The warning signs had been mounting for weeks. Aston Villa supporters taunted Old Trafford with chants of “You are going down with City,” while news broke of 16-year-old JJ Gabriel seeking a move to Real Madrid.

Even during their infamous 1973-74 relegation campaign, United had not started a season so poorly. Conceding 30 goals across all competitions is the worst defensive record of any team in Europe’s top five leagues, and trailing 2-0 inside four minutes against Chelsea set an unwanted Premier League record.
Despite an initial honeymoon period under Carrick, who took over last January following Ruben Amorim’s departure and guided the club to a third-place finish, momentum evaporated rapidly. Carrick’s position became untenable as defensive fragility and tactical predictability caught up with the side.
“Everyone analysed how we played, so we needed to change because if we didn’t, we would be left behind,” Martinez said after a defeat to Atletico Madrid.
Recruitment Flaws and Boardroom Scrutiny
Injuries and a glaring lack of squad depth have severely hampered progress. While Carrick managed to stabilise results by returning players to their preferred positions, such as pushing Bruno Fernandes higher up and resurrecting Kobbie Mainoo’s career, the club failed to adequately reinforce the squad in the summer, leaving a gaping hole at left-back and no established No.9.
Compounding the problem is a bloated squad with players difficult to shift, alongside growing fan animosity directed toward chief executive Omar Berrada, director of football Jason Wilcox, and minority owner Jim Ratcliffe. Banners displayed at Old Trafford “History. Dignity. Honour. You stole it all” highlight the depth of supporter disillusionment with the club’s current custodians.
Can Pochettino Turn the Tide?
Pochettino enters a deeply troubled environment. Known for demanding high-intensity pressing, the 54-year-old coach faces an immediate challenge in getting an underperforming squad to match his physical standards.
His pedigree is well-established after successful spells transforming Tottenham Hotspur and coaching in France and England, but questions remain over whether United can support him in the transfer market.
If negotiations finalise during the international break, Pochettino’s baptism of fire will arrive instantly with an away fixture against Liverpool at Anfield. Whether this marks the start of a genuine revival or another false dawn remains to be seen.